How Do T-Mobile's Plans Compare?

Summary: Wireless carrier T-Mobile has come out dressed as the 'Un-Carrier' and has hit the streets with new plans and payment models which have barely moved the needle from what users used to pay on T-Mobile...

By |

Wireless carrier T-Mobile has come out dressed as the 'Un-Carrier' and has hit the streets with new plans and payment models which have barely moved the needle from what users used to pay on T-Mobile. Although T-Mobile CEO, John Legere, has quickly dispensed with other carrier's subsidised cell phone tactics as confusing and almost malicious, T-Mobile's new wireless plan model separates the phone payment and the service plan payment with little financial chage for customers over 24 months. Think of it as being able to offer a lower headline price to attract customers but making it back with other payments over time, a lot like discount airline tickets where you pay for baggage and food separately after buying the cheap ticket.

So, how do these plans compare over 24 months now that you'll pay upfront for your new phone (or finance it with T-Mobile over 24 months which is the more likely option). We've compared the new total prices to paying off the device by way of a 24 month contract in a traditional wireless contract. We've used an example where you want a new Galaxy S3 (and added the best substitute device from Virgin Mobile and Boost, the Galaxy SII 4G, to be able to include some wider options).

All of the comparison numbers for all plan combinations on the Galaxy S3 can be compared here across 24 month period including the costs of the new Equipment Installation Plan on T-Mobile.

Light Usage - Entry Level

For light users we ran a sample comparison of 500 minutes, 500 messages and 500MB of data per month. Entry level customers had previously been offered a 500 minute plan from T-Mobile but now find themselves seeing unlimited calls and messages as their main option. As consumers move away from phone calls towards increased data usage via messaging applications like WhatsApp and iMessage, 500 minutes might be the right size for many people.

Medium Usage

For medium users, we looked at monthly usage of 1,000 minutes, 1,000 messages and 2GB of data per month with a new Galaxy S3 across 24 months. T-Mobile was the most competitive of the major carriers, but lost out again to the MVNO players like Ting and Virgin Mobile on the Galaxy S2 (although the Galaxy S2 is a weaker and cheaper phone).

Heavy Usage

For heavy individual users we've looked at unlimited calls, unlimited messages and 4G of data per month. You can go heavier in your usage comparisons and right up to 12GB comparisons, but we've started at 4GB which is pretty heavy for an individual. We've excluded some of the MVNO players as they can't offer 4GB at full speed (i.e. the most you can get from Virgin Mobile is 3.5GB at full speed).

Mobile Hotspot. If you want to use the T-Mobile unlimited data plan as a mobile hotspot, you'll need to add a separate data plan to allow this access as T-Mobile won't let you go unlimited on data if you're hot-spotting. You can keep your unlimited data for your phone and add hotspot access of 2.5GB for $10 or 4.5GB of access for $20 per month so that you can use your phone as modem.

No contract. The promise with T-Mobile's new plans is that they are they are contract free and you can upgrade anytime if you have already paid for your device upfront or paid off the financing of your device (which comes in at the same total cost with a 0% APR).

Contracted finance payments: Most people will likely end up financing their device via T-Mobile so you've still got a 24 month payment plan with T-Mobile's financing vendor. If you leave T-Mobile after 12 months, you're still going to have to pay the device off in full. The iPhone experience with Leap Wireless has shown just how resistant consumers are to high upfront costs as customers found the high upfront cost to be a barrier whilst Verizon celebrated a deluge of customers in the same period by offering and $0 iPhone 4 8GB which shows the subsidised model still draws in consumers.

Compare service plans and prices for your selected phone here

Note to Journalists: You’re welcome to use the infographics we’ve made and we’ve included a full size infographic of the T-Mobile plans compared against other carriers over 24 months below. Feel free to use it but we’d love it if you credited us appropriately as the source if you do choose to use it. Enjoy.

Like these Comparisons? We've put them together in one big Infographic

Embed this infographic in your website by copying and pasting the code below into your source code:


Tagged:


News by Topic

Phone Reviews

Featured

T-Mobile cuts prices for family plans, launches double data tablet deal

T-Mobile cuts prices for family plans, launches double data tablet deal

T-Mobile announces a surprise price drop for Simple Choice family plans, and...

Sprint's double data Family Share plan takes on T-Mobile

Sprint's double data Family Share plan takes on T-Mobile

Sprint has unveiled its new Family Share Pack, which offers double the amount...

Verizon launches $60 single line plan

Verizon launches $60 single line plan

Verizon has launched a $60-per-month deal aimed at customers looking for a...

 

Related News

T-Mobile adds more services to Music Freedom, but you'll have to wait for Google Play Music

T-Mobile adds more services to Music Freedom, but you'll have to wait for Google Play Music

​T-Mobile users on Simple Choice plans can keep turning it up to eleven, with...

T-Mobile quadruples Simple Starter data for $5, but is it worth it?

T-Mobile quadruples Simple Starter data for $5, but is it worth it?

T-Mobile is now offering to quadruple the amount of high-speed data for...

Cricket now paying T-Mobile and MetroPCS customers to switch service

Cricket now paying T-Mobile and MetroPCS customers to switch service

​It seems like everybody’s out to take down T-Mobile, with Cricket Wireless...

T-Mobile's 'rescue a friend' offer takes a dig at Sprint plans

T-Mobile's 'rescue a friend' offer takes a dig at Sprint plans

​Sprint may have beaten T-Mobile on pricing for unlimited data, but the...

T-Mobile takes on Sprint's Framily Plans with six-line offer

T-Mobile takes on Sprint's Framily Plans with six-line offer

T-Mobile has increased the Family Plan offer, allowing customers to add up to...

 

Guides

T-Mobile vs. Verizon: which is better for a single line plan?

T-Mobile vs. Verizon: which is better for a single line plan?

Depending on your choice of phone or plan, and how much you’re willing to pay...

T-Mobile vs Sprint: Family plan feud

T-Mobile vs Sprint: Family plan feud

If you're looking to get a single plan to cover your household, you have plenty...

Wi-Fi calling: who offers it and why you really want it

Wi-Fi calling: who offers it and why you really want it

If you're struggling to get bars on your cell phone network, you are a perfect...

Samsung Galaxy S5: cheapest $0 down plans

Samsung Galaxy S5: cheapest $0 down plans

The worst part about all of the awesome new phones coming out is that you need...

Is T-Mobile's JUMP! plan worth it?

Is T-Mobile's JUMP! plan worth it?

We've compared the pros and cons of going with JUMP!, versus sticking to a...

T-Mobile Test Drive: everything you need to know

T-Mobile Test Drive: everything you need to know

Keen to take T-Mobile for a spin? Here are the things you need to know about...

 

Compare phones & plans from the following carriers...

Sprint Cell Phone Plans Virgin Mobile Cell Phone Plans MetroPCS Cell Phone Plans Cricket Cell Phone Plans Straight Talk Cell Phone Plans U.S. Cellular Cell Phone Plans
T-Mobile Cell Phone Plans Republic Wireless Cell Phone Plans AmazonWireless Cell Phone Plans Ting Cell Phone Plans Boost Mobile Cell Phone Plans Red Pocket Cell Phone Plans
Verizon Wireless Cell Phone Plans AT&T Cell Phone Plans
 

Cell Phone Deals

How to Compare Family Plans

How to Compare Family Plans

Step by Step guide on how to compare family plans

NEW Samsung GALAXY S5 - Compare Plans and Prices

NEW Samsung GALAXY S5 - Compare Plans and Prices

Compare plans from all carriers on the new Galaxy S5

NEW HTC One M8 - Compare Plans and Prices

NEW HTC One M8 - Compare Plans and Prices

Compare plans from all carriers for the new HTC One M8

Compare Share and Family Plans for 2 or more lines

Compare Share and Family Plans for 2 or more lines

Compare multi-line share plans for all phones and payment options